Tuesday, January 3, 2012
Why Iowa Isn't Occupied: Wall Street 'Scapes Whipping Again
Always idiosyncratic, the Iowa caucuses may not be an early sign of very much to come in the 2012 campaign--especially not when Ron Paul and Rick Santorum, two men who have NO chance whatever to be president, are vying to win along with Romney. (Adding to Iowa's growing irrelevance: the new GOP primary rules, which award candidates delegates in proportional rather than winner-takes-all fashion until April 1).
But the utter ABSENCE of blame being directed at Wall Street, the chief culprit of America's economic disaster, in Iowa may well be a harbinger of what's to come. It has been the most deafening of silences. OK, this is just the Republicans, who from Mitt Romney on are mainly interested in pushing the Big Lie that Washington policy-makers, especially Fannie and Freddie, were mainly to blame, as I posted on Dec. 23. But even the Obama camp is looking to spread blame around beyond Wall Street, having hired a former financial services lobbyist as a key advisor for its 2012 campaign. The industry is lying low, even as it continues to quietly gut the meager Dodd-Frank reforms.
On a personal note, it was nice today to see Michiko Kakutani of The New York Times, still the preeminent book critic in America, favorably mention my book, Capital Offense, since the book does mainly blame Wall Street, blasting Washington only for its negligence in containing Wall Street. The plug came in Kakutani's tough review of Thomas Frank’s latest, "Pity the Billionaire." (Pity Tom too!), when she concluded that Frank’s “critical analysis of the causes and consequences of the crash of 2008 … lacks the intellectual rigor of the arguments that the economist Joseph Stiglitz laid out in his 2010 book, 'Freefall,' just as they lack the journalistic insights into Wall Street’s relationship with Washington that Michael Hirsh offered in his 2010 book, 'Capital Offense.'”
I doubt I'll ever make a living selling books, but it's awfully nice to be modestly praised by the reviewer who had the guts to deliver a proper comeuppance to the likes of Norman Mailer and Jonathan Franzen.
Monday, January 2, 2012
Liberals for Paul: What Happens When Both Sides Believe Govt is Corrupt
Say hello to Che Ron, the scourge of a corrupted American system. Liberals, having grown as leery of the morality of Big Government as libertarians, are now openly flirting with support for Ron Paul, even though he is opposed heart and soul to their central belief: using government to promote social equity. Republicans appear to be holding their noses and edging closer to Mitt Romney, though he is the embodiment of political expedience (even as they consider, and will just as quickly dump, their latest Great Red Hope in Iowa, Rick Santorum). Democrats will indulge in the usual harrumphing and self-hating before pulling the lever for their own false savior, Barack Obama. Around the world, skeptics of U.S. power in Europe and Asia never tire of pointing to American political paralysis and hubris-- yet they find they too find that, holding their noses, they must hew even closer to it. That's because the Europeans are proving to be even more economically dysfunctional than we are, which is why U.S. sovereign debt is still so sought after, and the Asians are more desirous of American protection than ever in the face of an aggressive China and an unpredictable Russia.
There are just no champions left, folks. We're not just compromising our True Beliefs, we're settling for a world in which there can no longer be True Beliefs. A world without true political heroes or viable ideologies. The only ideology left to us is the Least Worst Option. There's no liberalism; there's no conservatism; there's only Least-Worstism. Domestically, both progressives and right-wingers are equally disgusted with their political options, which lie only in the corrupted political center. Obama, who came into office promising a new era of postpartisanship, fell victim naively to the worst partisan gridlock in memory. And he never opened up a true new national debate. Globally, we have entered an era in which the Last Superpower is no longer trusted or capable, but where there is no one to replace it. So we are adrift in a leaderless world.
Perhaps I -- we all-- are overstating things. True, I have been pretty hard on Obama myself. But Ron Paul is the falsest savior of all. He is plainly a wackjob who not only has no chance of being president, but whom it is hard to imagine anyone on either side of the aisle ever entrusting with a senior federal job. Santorum was once considered one of America's dumbest senators by his own colleagues and appears to have learned nothing from a decade of neocon disasters. And Romney, well, he's played ideological whack-a-mole for so long there's no telling what he would really do as president. Which brings us back to ... Obama.
Still, I think we can learn something from the Liberals-for-Paul boomlet. Both the Left and Right need to shed some of their mythology. Glenn Greenwald, in a powerful broadside, observes that progressives are flirting with Paul for the simple reason that Obama "has done heinous things with the power he has been vested," including covert wars with both Islamist extremists and with Iran. Greenwald accuses progressives of not conducting an honest debate with themselves in which they admit the real tradeoffs of this Democratic administration: i.e., we'll accept unchecked executive power in which Muslim children are killed as collateral damage and bankers are secretly bailed out, as long as we can have fewer cuts to entitlements and a more progressive Supreme Court. Says Greenwald: "It is the classic lesser-of-two-evils rationale, the key being that it explicitly recognizes that both sides are “evil”: meaning it is not a Good v. Evil contest but a More Evil v. Less Evil contest."
Yeah, that's about right. It's Least-Worstism, as I said. There is evidence, of course, that Obama's policies, as costly as they sometimes are, have been effective, at least against Public Enemy No. 1 of the last decade, Al Qaeda. But that's going to do little to appease liberals, or win over anti-government conservatives. Clearly we need not just a new politics but a new set of ideas to fill the vacuum, as I've tried to argue economically. If liberals are now pining for a guy at the opposite end of the spectrum -- Che Ron -- then we have reached the End of the Old Divide. The failure of the ideologies of both Left and Right has come full circle. The only question is whether we will continue to go around in circles...
(Picture credit: http://thesamerowdycrowd.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/ron-paul-liberal.jpg?w=236&h=300)
Friday, December 30, 2011
Summing up 2011: Drowning Homeowners, Soaring Banks, Historic Inequity
(picture credit: http://www.moonbattery.com/Underwater-House.jpg)
As we await the outcome of the tea-party-dominated vote in Iowa--a tea party movement that got its name from Rick Santelli's rant on CNBC against Washington's "subsidizing losers' mortgages" in 2009 --let's take stock. More than two years in, this must be considered one of the most lopsided and pathological recoveries--a non-recovery, really--in American history. Here is what does not add up in our economy: even today, no one wants to risk the "moral hazard" of helping the "losers" -- the deadbeat mortgage holders who aroused the ire of the libertarian Santelli -- in a big way, lest this action undermine the proper working of capitalism. And yet we've just spent the last four years pouring hundreds of billions of dollars into helping deadbeat banks (while asking nothing in return), thus also undermining capitalism.
Why aren't we talking about the inequity in this? The "losers' mortgages," of course, continue to be the biggest dead weight on American recovery. The underwater mortgage and foreclosure crisis has prevented a resurgence of demand in a consumer economy that, because of stagnant wages, had become dependent on debt and refinancing for growth until the crash. So it is an economy that now has no great new life in it, with so many households still drowning in the deluge left behind by an unnatural-- this had little to do with authentic capitalism, Mr. Santelli! -- and fraud-driven housing mania, as I wrote in a post on Dec. 20.
On the other hand, the banks are soaring, artificially sustained by Ben Bernanke's Fed. This positive trend has been ironically turbocharged by the eurocrisis, with European banks dumping assets to be picked over by their U.S. brethren. Yet the American banks continue to defy even the meager government efforts to force them to renegotiate more underwater mortgages. From the very beginning, says Diane Thompson of the National Consumer Law Center, the admininstration and the Congress "underestimated the amount of fraud. And I think they overestimated the good will of the bankers. From the beginning, all the proposals were too small." Congress kicked its biggest opportunity away in 2009 by declining to alter bankruptcy rules and thus make it easier for homeowners to get out of bad mortgages, and the Obama administration didn't fight the issue very hard.
Maybe the strangest thing of all is that Barack Obama's 2012 re-election probably hinges on working this dead weight off the economy. And yet, with just 11 months to go, he remains curiously detached from the problem, still deferring to Timmy Geithner, his let-the-banks-be Treasury Secretary, who never met a Wall Street firm he didn't want to protect.
No one seems interested in discussing how nonsensical it is to be worrying about moral hazard for people but not for banks. (When was the last time you heard a good debate about the "too-big-to-fail" problem?) And even here the problem of forgiving "deadbeat" borrowers was always exaggerated, argues Kathleen Engel of Suffolk University, one of the most prescient observers of predatory lending and fraud in the country. As she points out, "The people who are walking away from their homes are generally investor-owners, not owner occupiers. Yeah, there's some reason to be concerned about moral hazard, but they still can be sued for deficiency judgements if they walk away."
Even the Justice Department, the SEC and other agencies have been passive, despite the evidence of massive documentation fraud in which the biggest banks were complicit. The one agency that could make a difference, the new and independent Consumer Finance Protection Bureau, remains hamstrung and leaderless because of GOP obstructionism.
No one in power wants to pressure Fannie and Freddie -- which have become too toxic to touch, again because of politics -- to renegotiate terms and write down principle. Currently, notes Thompson, "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac don't even //allow// principle reductions." And Congress continues to hold up Dodd-Frank reform, including new mortgage rules.
This is what really ails us. It is the sclerosis eating at the heart of our economy. The only solution for a government-created crisis--yes, it is that, though not the way the tea partiers think--is a government-created solution. Naturally, you won't hear much of it discussed in Iowa over the weekend....
Wednesday, December 28, 2011
America's New Super Pac Politics
Unraveling Newt Gingrich's hypocrisies is not unlike peeling an onion--there are so many layers that you can't help but cry and give up the task. Here are the first few layers of Newt's latest multiple-flip-flop: Recall that Gingrich was a stout defender of Citizens United, the right-wing group that precipitated the infamous Supreme Court decision that opened the way to Super PACs, and that Newt allegedly used millions of dollars from his now-defunct Super PAC, American Solutions for Winning the Future, to fly around the country promoting himself, although candidates are supposed to be divorced from these new campaign monstrosities.
Then, a few days ago, a newly "positive" Gingrich decided to make a principled stand against the impact of Super PAC politics. He whined about the effect that Romney's Super PAC was having in Iowa by airing negative ads against Newt. Romney should be able to "influence" the group, Newt declared with his usual self-righteous certainty. How, he thundered, could Romney hope to influence Congress or even China or Russia if he couldn't get get his Super PAC in hand? "The only person who profits from Republican ads attacking other Republicans is Barack Obama and I think it is pretty reprehensible behavior on the part of some of the candidates," Gingrich added. ("It's against the law" to coordinate with one's Super Pac, Romney reasonably countered).
Well, now Newt has apparently decided that Romney is right--or at least that it's impossible after all to control one's Super PAC. His own new group, Strong America Now, is calling "Romney is the second most dangerous man in America" after Obama. Nothing negative about that, I guess.
Newt Gingrich, there's a steady man for you.
What this really demonstrates is that not even the candidates understand any longer how the new Super PAC machine created by the Citizens United decision is upending American politics. What the Super PACs are already doing to twist Iowa's much-touted grassroots caucus process out of shape is only an early sign of what's to come ...
(Picture credit: http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/11/18/super-pac-man-gobbles-up-regulators%E2%80%99-time-patience/)
What this really demonstrates is that not even the candidates understand any longer how the new Super PAC machine created by the Citizens United decision is upending American politics. What the Super PACs are already doing to twist Iowa's much-touted grassroots caucus process out of shape is only an early sign of what's to come ...
(Picture credit: http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/11/18/super-pac-man-gobbles-up-regulators%E2%80%99-time-patience/)
Tuesday, December 27, 2011
Check out : Countdown to Iowa
How the Iowa caucuses could be putting themselves out of business: Countdown to Iowa
Monday, December 26, 2011
'Momentous'? Obama-Romney will be close--but booooring
It's not often that you get to make fun of Newt Gingrich and a liberal Washington Post columnist in the same breath--but we've arrived a such a moment! Day after day, the Newt-ster is reminding normal people on all sides of the spectrum why they're frightened by the prospect of a Gingrich presidency: the hypocrisy is one reason, but mainly it's his pretentious, vainglorious, overreaching rhetoric, which the logorrheic candidate seems incapable of moderating or containing. Two examples from recent days: Newt believes the best "analogy" to his being kept off the ballot in the Virginia primary is Pearl Harbor, according to TalkingPointsMemo, quoting Gingrich campaign director Michael Krull. It was a setback, Krull explained, but "in the end we will stand victorious.”
Somehow, in Newt's addled consciousness, his failure to get enough signatures for a state primary adds up to the beginning of World War II. So... what would a real challenge like Pearl Harbor mean?
Then, campaigning in Iowa, Gingrich declared: "This is the most important election since 1860, because there's such a dramatic difference between the best food-stamp president in history and the best paycheck candidate." The election of 1860, of course, was about whether the nation would dissolve into Civil War. Uhhhh, WHAT? Yes, Newt, we are a politically divided nation. But I haven't heard any secession talk lately. Nonetheless WashPost columnist E.J. Dionne, departing today from his usual informed sensibleness, cited Gingrich's ridiculous 1860 analogy in concluding that "everyone agrees that the 2012 election will be a turning point involving one of the most momentous choices in American history."
No, they don't agree. At least I don't. "For the first time since Barry Goldwater made the effort in 1964, the Republican Party is taking a run at overturning the consensus that has governed U.S. political life since the Progressive era," Dionne writes. To wit: Republicans want to remove government from American life, and Obama wants to impose it. OMG, we've been hearing this since the Reagan era, and the reality is nothing like the rhetoric. Reagan launched a deregulatory era but did not cut the size of government; he increased it. So did the two Bushes. The tea-party-driven GOP rhetoric we're hearing now is an angry reaction to that, but let's not overreact ourselves.
In truth, Obama and his likeliest opponent, Romney, are far closer in mindset and philosophy than anyone is willing to acknowledge just now. Obama, despite his image, has sought to placate business and left Wall Street largely intact, and he is taking a far tougher line on foreign policy--one that reflects a traditional GOP "realpolitik" view and a dramatic ratcheting up of covert war-- than is generally acknowledged, even when it comes to China. Romney, increasingly desperate to win over his base against an onslaught of "Not-Romneys," has allowed his rhetoric to grow more inflamed on the trail, including commitments to a balanced-budget amendment and partially voucherizing Medicare as well as eliminating Obamacare. But based on his history, if he gets the nomination he is unlikely to follow through fully on these overheated pre-primary pledges and do many things very differently, either on the economy or foreign policy. The problems of slow growth, chronic deficits, and an overextended military will inevitably lend themselves to similar solutions from either an Obama or a Romney administration.
Dionne acknowledged that Gingrich's metaphor was "cheap and inaccurate," but he nonetheless took Newt's "historical sweep" seriously. "It says a great deal" about the importance the election, Dionne concluded generously, "that Gingrich chose to reach all the way back to the election that helped spark the Civil War."
Sorry E.J. It only says a great deal about Newt.
Friday, December 23, 2011
The Big Lie Grows
The Right can't agree on much these days--witness the Boehner-McConnell miscue over payroll tax cuts--but conservatives are eagerly converging around the idea that their Sugar Daddy No. 1, Wall Street, was largely blameless in the biggest financial crash since the Depression. We're hearing a whole new iteration of a very tired claim: that government housing policies dating back to Bill Clinton and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the quasi-governmental lenders, were Ground Zero of the crisis. Gov. Rick Perry, whose cluelessness only seems to grow the longer he spends on the trail, not only wants to "free up Wall Street" to save the economy, but in Iowa this week he labeled Fannie and Freddie a "modern day Bonnie and Clyde." Gingrich and Romney have joined in identifying Fan and Fred as Public Enemies No.1.
Now the GOP has a willing accomplice in that weakest of regulatory sisters: the SEC. Having proved inept at nailing Wall Street over the last three years despite the biggest financial fraud in history--what I once called the Too Big to Jail problem-- the SEC is going for the easy pickings, Fannie and Freddie. This has lent credibility to the loons of the Right, as Joe Nocera noted the other day. It is also exactly what we have long expected from the the seriously compromised SEC chairwoman, Mary Schapiro, who spent most of her career as a tool of the financial industry, and her Deutsche Bank-engendered enforcement chief, Robert Khuzami. As head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in the mid-90s, Schapiro failed to assert control over OTC derivatives trading, despite scams that were already so worrisome that one of her successors, Brooksley Born, called them “the hippopotamus under the rug.” Later, when Schapiro was running the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA)--Wall Street's abysmally incompetent "self-regulatory" body--she also missed Bernie Madoff's Ponzi scheme. In both her jobs Schapiro followed a pattern: she tended to aggressively investigate relatively minor violations while failing to see the hippopotamus-size frauds in the room. As Bill Singer, a former attorney for the National Association of Securities Dealers who's become a leading critic of regulators, told me back in 2009: "My ultimate concern with Mary Schapiro is, we cannot afford to have the new SEC chair come in with a bucket of whitewash and a bucket of plaster. We need a wrecking ball."
Were Fannie and Freddie corrupt? Of course. I wrote that more than three years ago, as did many others. But to argue that they were prime movers in this crisis is to argue that the moon is made of green cheese rather than rock and dust. It's not just that new Fed data makes clear how deep and extensive the infection of bad lending on Wall Street--and therefore culpability--became. What's more significant is the obvious evidence that while Fannie and Freddie got involved, they were very late to the game, and they were at best fellow travelers.
As Bloomberg BusinessWeek reported this week, at the peak of the mortgage mania in 2005-06, only 6 percent of all subprime loans involved lenders or borrowers governed by the law, under which Fannie and Freddie were required to operate, according to Federal Reserve data. The rest was shadow banking encouraged or sponsored by Wall Street. “The available evidence seems to run counter to the contention that the CRA [the Community Reinvestment Act encouraging loans to low-income borrowers] contributed in any substantive way to the current mortgage crisis,” Fed economists Neil Bhutta and Glenn Canner wrote in 2009.
But what really puts the kabosh on the Fannie/Freddie theory is that -- as I wrote a year ago and go into considerable detail in Capital Offense -- the seeds of the financial crash of 2008 were planted decades before the subprime securitization market took off. The notorious advent of "CDOs," or collateralized debt obligations, were not something new under the sun. They were only the latest generation of a long lineage of deceptive Wall Street securitization practices that developed independent of Fannie or Freddie or government-sponsored loans or real estate. To the extent that government was complicit, it was mainly in its willingness to stop regulating Wall Street and ignore the system of institutionalized fraud that was emerging.
Among other changes, the 2000 Commodity Futures Modernization Act created what may have been the world’s most laissez-faire market in over-the-counter derivatives; the Glass-Steagall repeal in 1999 erased the remaining firewalls between federally insured banks and the riskiest trading practices; and the Securities and Exchange Commission lowered limits on leverage whenever asked, creating a pyramid of debt. Increasingly complex products and practices regularly blew up—think of the 1994 bankruptcy of Orange County, Calif., and the 1998 collapse of Long Term Capital Management—but the result was only more deregulation.
The heart of the issue had to do with the burgeoning markets in over-the-counter derivatives, credit default swaps and brain-crushingly complex structured finance products. The key to these trades was as much deception back then as it later became during the CDO craze. “Quants” on the street -- many of them former physicists or other math geniuses -- were always finding complex new ways to repackage assets. The structured-finance schemes usually followed the same theme: The key was to take junk -- risky but very high-yielding bonds or securities denominated in pesos or Thai baht or Malaysian ringgits -- and disguise them well enough so that pension investors or insurance companies or others thought they were buying investment-grade stuff denominated in dollars.
These practices were direct forerunners of what many of the same Wall Street firms later did during the subprime bubble. The approach was the same: disguise bad assets as better ones. This was achieved by euphemizing poor credit risks as “subprime borrowers” and lumping them together with better credit risks within vastly complex CDOs, then slicing and dicing the loans so that investors--indeed, even the CEOs of the Wall Street firms themselves--no longer understood what was safe and what wasn't. Need further proof? Consider: by 2006, 44.7 percent of all securitized subprime mortgages in the country were "stated income" or no-document loans of the kind the GSEs couldn't engage in, according to Patrick Madigan, an Iowa assistant attorney general. "There's only one reason for that high number, and that's fraud." Fraud of precisely the kind that a securitization-hungry Wall Street had been engaging in for a decade or more before the subprime bubble.
After the mortgage-refinancing boom of 2003–04, demand from Wall Street for fresh subprime "product" for new CDOs grew so intense that lending standards nationwide disintegrated. To meet the Street's demand for a steady supply, lenders kept reaching lower and lower down the scale of quality in both property and borrowers. The investment banks were so desperate for more mortgage-backed securities to sell that some of them cut deals with the big nonbank lenders to deliver billions of dollars worth of loans a month, no questions asked. "The drug lord was Wall Street. This was money looking for people to exploit," Jim Rokakis, the treasurer of Ohio's Cuyahoga County, which was particularly hard hit, told me in 2008.
Yes, Fannie and Freddie got into the game at some point -- but it was a game that had been invented by Wall Street years earlier. QED.
Thursday, December 22, 2011
Good News, Bad News Barack
On one hand, the economic numbers are looking up for Obama at the moment, and ECB head Mario Draghi is finally fulfilling his promise: he appears to be taking the necessary actions to prevent the eurozone from collapsing and thereby becoming the biggest factor weighing on Obama's chances in 2012. On the other hand, even Iowans are coming to realize that Newt is presidentially challenged, unsuited in both temperament and character to be in the White House. So Obama is now more certain than ever to be facing Mitt Romney, who for all his many flaws is realistically the only one who can beat him. To make matters worse, Iraq may be going downhill fast--and Mitt has hit him hard over the failed troop extension talks.
So where does that leave the election odds? I think Obama's biggest trump card may end up being the divide within the GOP exposed by the new House-Senate rift over payroll tax cut extensions. John Boehner's jittery eleventh hour cave today, and the GOP's long weekend of humiliating internecine tension, is further evidence that the Republicans don't know who they really want to be. In the broadest philosophical sense, there is GOP consensus on pursuing the Bush tax cuts, changing the tax code and reducing entitlements. But as soon as you get into the details of many of these issues, confusion reigns, as seen in the apparent inability of Boehner and McConnell to communicate. There is a new confusion over trade policy, over voucherizing Medicare (the sharp dispute between Ryan and Gingrich), and which programs are to be cut. And we haven't even begun to talk about foreign policy, where the tensions between the old neocon camp (best manifested by Santorum, I think) and the traditionalists (like Huntsman) remain completely unresolved within the party: have you ever seen a more confused and less united response to any foreign policy than the various debate comments that have come out of the GOP candidates about Obama's Libya policy?
Obama's botched many opportunities already, as we have tirelessly pointed out, but he's very lucky in his adversaries. He still has a chance to look leaderly, and presidential anew, in 2012....
So where does that leave the election odds? I think Obama's biggest trump card may end up being the divide within the GOP exposed by the new House-Senate rift over payroll tax cut extensions. John Boehner's jittery eleventh hour cave today, and the GOP's long weekend of humiliating internecine tension, is further evidence that the Republicans don't know who they really want to be. In the broadest philosophical sense, there is GOP consensus on pursuing the Bush tax cuts, changing the tax code and reducing entitlements. But as soon as you get into the details of many of these issues, confusion reigns, as seen in the apparent inability of Boehner and McConnell to communicate. There is a new confusion over trade policy, over voucherizing Medicare (the sharp dispute between Ryan and Gingrich), and which programs are to be cut. And we haven't even begun to talk about foreign policy, where the tensions between the old neocon camp (best manifested by Santorum, I think) and the traditionalists (like Huntsman) remain completely unresolved within the party: have you ever seen a more confused and less united response to any foreign policy than the various debate comments that have come out of the GOP candidates about Obama's Libya policy?
Obama's botched many opportunities already, as we have tirelessly pointed out, but he's very lucky in his adversaries. He still has a chance to look leaderly, and presidential anew, in 2012....
Wednesday, December 21, 2011
A Great Recession Cover-Up?
Per today's housing data, we keep learning that the Big Crash was worse than many of us knew. But perhaps not worse than EVERYONE knew. How much was the Obama administration and the Fed covering up? The Fed, we learned, committed far more than anyone imagined to saving Wall Street (some $29 trillion, according to Bloomberg: see my 12/10 post, "Two Awful Numbers"). And some of the losers in the great debate inside the administration, like former Council of Economic Advisors chair Christina Romer, gave us signals of how bad things really were even as they lost their fight for a bigger stimulus. Romer, in 2009, said the blow to public confidence from those harrowing months of 2008 was actually much worse than what happened in 1929. “The collapse in wealth was far more dramatic,” Romer said. “All told, household wealth fell 17 percent between December 2007 and December 2008, more than five times the decline in 1929.” Were both the administration and the Fed--both so vested in creating the unregulated and out-of-control financial system that came to grief -- simply in denial about the extent of the disaster they had created? I think the evidence is compelling...
Tuesday, December 20, 2011
A Hero of the Housing Crisis
The housing market of the 2000s "was the Wild West, and there was no sheriff in town. ... The only difference is that in the old days, people robbed the banks. Now the banks were robbing the people."
--JIM ROKAKIS, then-Cuyahoga County Treasurer, quoted in "Mortgages and Madness," Newsweek, May 24, 2008
There were few people in the country who saw into the pathology of the Wall-Street-engendered housing mania as deeply and as early as Jim Rokakis, whom I quoted in that article back in 2008 and whose ideas heavily informed my book Capital Offense. Not surprisingly (at least to me), Rokakis is also one of those on the front lines of a solution, as profiled on "60 Minutes" last Sunday. Knowing that the housing implosion was not natural market condition--and that therefore it couldn't be expected to "clear" like a normal market either (an insight that still eludes the Obama administration)--Rokakis has pushed for years for a "land bank" program that will demolish run-down homes left over from the bubble collapse that even the banks don't want any more, so that blighted neighborhoods can recover. Now he's finally got it...
Rokakis, the county treasurer, was puzzled in the early 2000s when he saw real-estate values soaring in "the mistake by the Lake," as Cleveland was sometimes known. Rokakis knew the rust-belt market had always been stagnant; what was different now? So he was able to see, long before most, that it was all driven by Wall Street; that unethical mortgage brokers were being encouraged by securitization-hungry Wall Street firms to loan almost any amount to anybody, even in places once bypassed by the real-estate market. The finance community in New York knew that, in an ever-appreciating real estate market nationwide, even indigent mortgage holders could always refinance, even in backwaters like Cleveland. And Wall Street, of course, would then snap up the //next round// of loans as well and bundle them into yet a new round of securities. This no longer had anything to do with real-estate values in Cleveland or any kind of a normal market, Rokakis realized. Deeply worried, Rokakis attempted to awaken the interest of the Fed and other regulatory authorities to the emerging bubble, and the inner dynamics that were driving it. The authorities, of course, had no interest in what this hayseed from the heartland had to say, as was typical in those years. The result: the greatest crash since the Great Depression, and a Wall Street that to this day has escaped whipping.
For those who are heartened by the upturn in national housing numbers announced today, take heed. Unless interventionist programs like Rokakis's are created on a national scale, and Washington gets much tougher with the banks (forcing them to do what it should have three years ago, which is to launch a program of writing down principal as well as interest), we will still be writing stories and blog posts about the underwater mortgage market and an ass-dragging economy a few years from now. As the MSNBC story above notes: "There are multiple, strong headwinds that will hold back [housing] recovery. The biggest is the long pipeline of housing foreclosures glutting the market with houses owned by banks looking to unload them at bargain prices."
Rokakis, as always, has the most sensible (and thus least heeded) advice: "You`re going to have to write down principal balances. Because if you don`t write down the principle to something that`s more realistic, it just guarantees that more people will walk away and more people will default." But nothing like this, or salvage programs like Cleveland's, can possibly occur without aggressive government intervention that does not appear forthcoming.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







